Math with Bad DrawingsCartoon Archive

Time Immemorial

March 13, 2018

A grandiose claim about the ancient question of defining numbers set-theoretically is corrected: it's a 19th-century question.

Use this cartoon

Free for classrooms, worksheets, slides and other non-commercial use under CC BY-NC 4.0, with credit to Ben Orlin.

Cartoon by Ben Orlin, Math with Bad Drawings. https://cartoons.mathwithbaddrawings.com/2018-03-13-time-immemorial/ (CC BY-NC 4.0)
Transcript

A: "Since time immemorial, mankind has asked: What are numbers? Moreover, can we provide rigorous set theoretic constructions for them?"

B: "'Time immemorial'? That game pretty much originated in 19th-century analytic philosophy."

A: "Oh I thought 'since time immemorial' meant 'no one can remember a time.' Like, 'mankind has never asked this.'" B: "Ah. Unconventional usage, but carry on."

Topics
Sets & Infinity › Set TheoryLogic & Proof › Foundations of MathMath Culture › History of MathNumber & Arithmetic › Number Systems
Level
College
Themes
Language & WordplayMathematiciansHistory & Holidays